From Data to Decisions: Alternative Data Sources supporting SME Lending

Small and medium enterprises (SMEs) and microbusinesses are the backbone of many emerging and developing markets, driving job creation and economic growth. Yet, access to affordable credit remains a significant challenge. Traditional credit scoring models, heavily reliant on financial history and collateral, often exclude these businesses, as they lack formal documentation or credit histories.

The rise of alternative data credit scoring 

Alternative data is changing the game. By leveraging non-traditional data sources like behavioural analytics, psychometric assessments, and device metadata, lenders can develop more comprehensive and inclusive risk models. These data-driven approaches are bridging the gap for SMEs and enabling financial institutions to unlock a previously untapped market. 

1. Understanding Alternative Data in Lending 

What is alternative data credit scoring? 

Alternative data refers to information not traditionally used by financial institutions to evaluate creditworthiness. It includes behavioural patterns, digital footprints, transaction histories, and more. Unlike traditional methods, which depend on credit scores and bank statements, alternative data explores the borrower’s broader financial and social behaviour. 

Why SMEs and microbusinesses benefit from alternative data 

SMEs and microbusinesses are the lifeblood of economic growth; however they need investment to thrive, but they often face the same tough due diligence as much larger businesses, leaving them excluded by conventional credit systems. Alternative data provides a means to assess their risk accurately, enabling lenders to extend credit where it was previously deemed too risky.

2. The Role of Alternative Data in SME Credit Risk Assessment 

Key metrics from alternative data sources 

Lenders analyse various metrics to gauge creditworthiness. Behavioural analytics, such as spending patterns, and psychometric data reveal character traits like reliability and risk tolerance. Device metadata, such as mobile app usage or location patterns, provides real-time insights into a borrower’s habits. 

How alternative data improves risk models 

These non-traditional metrics enhance predictive accuracy, helping lenders identify creditworthy borrowers more effectively. Case studies show that lenders using alternative data models experience reduced default rates and increased approval rates for previously excluded groups. Alternative data credit scores apply to working capital, unsecured term loans, credit cards, asset finance and more. 

3. Exploring the 4 alternative data sources transforming SME lending

1. Psychometric Assessments 

Psychometric assessments measure a borrower’s personality traits, such as honesty, risk appetite, and financial discipline. These tests can take different forms. At Begini, we offer a gamified user experience to ensure high completion rates while also maximising data collected to evaluate behaviours linked to creditworthiness. 

Applications in Micro SME Lending: 

  • Widely used in emerging markets where formal credit histories are unavailable. 
  • Helps predict repayment behaviour based on psychological attributes.

 

Example: A fintech in Africa used psychometric testing to assess rural entrepreneurs, achieving a 30% reduction in defaults compared to traditional methods. 

2. Mobile Device Metadata 

Device metadata refers to information captured from mobile phones, such as app usage patterns, geolocation, and even battery charging habits. These data points can indicate a borrower’s stability and financial reliability. 

Benefits for SME Lending: 

  • Enables real-time insights into business operations for microenterprises. 
  • Helps lenders detect signs of financial distress early. 


Privacy Considerations: 

While metadata offers invaluable insights, it must be handled with strict compliance to data privacy regulations to build trust among borrowers. Begini’s device data solution does not collect any personally identifiable information and ensure privacy by design.  

3. Payment and Transaction History 

Non-traditional payment records, such as mobile money transactions or e-commerce activity, provide a detailed picture of cash flow. 

Use in Credit Scoring: 

  • Tracks income consistency and spending habits for informal businesses. 
  • Serves as a substitute for formal bank statements in credit evaluations. 

Example: In Southeast Asia, some lenders rely on transaction histories from mobile wallets to evaluate micro-SME borrowers, significantly expanding financial inclusion. 

4. Utility and Rent Payment Records 

Regular payments for utilities, rent, or phone bills serve as indicators of financial discipline and repayment ability. 

Advantages in Emerging Markets: 

  • Provides reliable data for individuals and businesses outside formal banking systems. 
  • Can be automated through partnerships with utility companies to streamline the data collection process. 

4. The Advantages and Challenges of Alternative Risk Models

Advantages of Alternative Data in Lending 

  • Enhanced Inclusion: Enables access to credit for previously underserved populations. 
  • Increased Predictive Power: Improves loan performance by accurately identifying credit risks. 
  • Operational Efficiency: Automates decision-making processes, reducing costs and approval times. 

Challenges and Limitations 

  • Data Privacy and Security: Borrowers may be hesitant to share data, necessitating robust privacy protections and education around the security of the solution. 
  • Regulatory Hurdles: In some markets regulations and clear guidelines are still being developed. 

 

5. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) 

1. What is alternative data, and how is it used in credit scoring? 

Alternative data includes non-traditional information like psychometric assessments and transaction histories, used to assess creditworthiness for individuals and businesses lacking formal credit records. 

2. Why are traditional credit scoring methods inadequate for SMEs? 

Traditional models rely on collateral and financial history, which SMEs often lack, making alternative data essential for assessing their credit risk. 

3. How do psychometric assessments measure creditworthiness? 

They evaluate psychological traits like reliability and risk tolerance, providing insights into the borrower’s willingness to repay loans. 

4. Is it ethical to use device metadata for SME lending decisions? 

Yes, if used responsibly with borrower consent and in compliance with privacy regulations, device metadata can enhance risk assessments. It gives the borrower control over their own data and the choice to use their data for services which are meaningful to them. Data should never be taken without users explained consent.  

5. Can small lenders afford to implement alternative data solutions? 

Yes, many fintech platforms offer scalable solutions tailored for small lenders, enabling cost-effective adoption. 

6. How can alternative risk models be regulated in emerging markets? 

Governments and regulators are establishing enabling frameworks that ensure data privacy, transparency, and ethical use of alternative data. 

 

Conclusion 

Summarising the impact of alternative data in SME lending 

Alternative data is reshaping SME lending by addressing long-standing challenges in assessing credit risk. With tools like psychometric assessments, mobile device metadata, and payment histories, lenders can make more inclusive and accurate decisions. 

Financial institutions that embrace these innovations are finding a competitive advantage in rapidly developing markets. Partnering with fintech providers, investing in data infrastructure, and adhering to ethical practices are crucial steps. 

At Begini, we specialize in leveraging alternative data to empower lenders and expand financial inclusion. Reach out to learn how we can help transform your lending strategy. 

 

Want to know more?

If you have a question about the potential of alternative data, or you'd like to see our platform in action, drop us a line?